FlashMBA.com: The Evolution of Professional Skills Training

Tactics Tuesday: 6 of One, Half a Dozen of the Other

Posted by Andrew on Jan 10, 2017 8:30:35 AM

Name: 6 of One, Half a Dozen of the Other

AKA: Pick One.

Intent:   Convince your counter-party to choose between two packages of value that are both equally favorable to you.

Style: Appears collaborative but can be fairly competitive if your duel proposal is set high enough.6 of 1, Pick One

Counter: Cherry pick the parts of both packages that are most favorable to you - and then make it more favorable by 20%.

Combinations: This works best as the first counter. Your opening anchor position will be more aggressive, and this works best as your first concession.

Example: Bob wants to hire Alvin’s design firm to build an app for a client’s retail business. He offers Alvin a choice of two proposals:

  • finish the work on a 4-week deadline with unlimited revisions (over 6 months) for a fee of $20,000;

  • or take 6 weeks with 3 revisions over the course of a year for $17,500.

While it may seem that Bob is giving his counterpart an attractive choice, the fact is that he is hijacking the agenda and attempting to force Alvin to accept his terms.

Let’s look at Bob’s real agenda. Remember – Bob is hiring Alvin to perform a service.






Like (for Bob)


4 Weeks




6 Weeks

3 Revisions

Need it – or no deal


8 Weeks

1 Revision


Bob is a fairly aggressive negotiator, so he would be sure to anchor first with an aggressive proposal -- offering Alvin $17,500 for a tight deadline of 4 weeks, and unlimited revisions to the project as the client’s wants and needs became more clarified. This is a great deal for Bob – quick, cheap, and safe (since Alvin would be on the hook for an open-ended service contract). Alvin would, of course, push back – and he might even introduce his own variables, such as ownership of the intellectual property or cash up-front.

6 of 1 is Bob’s way of orienting the negotiation to ensure a favorable outcome. Let’s look at it more closely:



Variable 1

Variable 2

Variable 3

Like   (for Bob)







Need C C


He frames his counter-offer this way:

         Option 1:    Var 1: B   Var 2: A   Var 3: A

         Option 2:    Var 1: A   Var 2: B   Var 3: B

As you might be able to guess, Bob is indifferent between Option 1 and Option 2. They are both favorable to him. Even if Alvin responds “aggressively” and demands the best of both -- $20,000 with a 6 week deadline and limited post-delivery service – Bob would still be right in the middle of his range. He would then find it relatively easy to lift Alvin on price and maybe shave a week off the deadline – effectively closing somewhere between his Like and Intermediate range. Good deal for Bob.

6 of 1 works best when there is a wide range of potential variables and the deal includes service or some other highly subjective measure. The key is to create two bundles of variables that you consider to be of equal value, and then make the counter-party feel that the choice is all his. If you deploy this one correctly, you’ll stay well above your bottom line.

Topics: 6 of 1, Negotiation, Millennial, Six of One, Tactical Tuesday, Tactics

Written by Andrew

Something Powerful

FlashMBA.com -  Cross Cultural Skills for Modern Business leaders.

FlashMBA teaches cross-culture business skills for professionals who demand fast, high-impact learning that focuses on real solutions.

  • Negotiation
  • Communication
  • Critical thinking
  • Management
  • Leadership 

Subscribe to Email Updates


Professional skills training delivered in a fast, flash-card format.

Online classes, slideshows, videos and articles focusing on soft-skills.

  • Negotiation
  • Communication
  • Leadership
  • Problem-solving

Manage your skills training like you manage your career.

Subscribe to Email Updates

FlashMBA's Negotiators Toolkit
Join the Managing Millennials Newletter

ChinaSolved: Business Solutions for International Negotiators

The International Negotiator: Apple in China (from FlashMBA.com)

Nothing stays off the table forever. Apple recently removed access to VPN services on its China App Store in compliance with government wishes. VPNs, or Virtual Private Networks, are the chief method...Read more

3 Negotiating Takeaways from the NK Coal Boat Maneuver

Win-Win with Chinese Characteristics The new US administration seemed to score a big coup in Asia last week, when China blocked a fleet of North Korean cargo ships carrying coal to Chinese markets....Read more

Three Negotiating Issues to Watch at the Xi Trump Meeting

The upcoming Xi – Trump meeting is the first face-to-face sit down between the two leaders.  The US side has been clear about what it wants from China, but it’s not quite as clear what it plans...Read more

The Future of US-China Commercial Relations: Welcome to the Multiconomy

Takeaway – Established Western brands will continue to defend their global leadership positions for a while yet, but Chinese corporates are taking control of growing niches and new...Read more

5 Negotiating Lessons from Sec. of State Tillerson’s Beijing Trip

That treacherous opening Chinese toast. US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson made his first official visit to China last weekend, and the White House probably sees it as one of the bright spots in a...Read more

Share FlashMBA Articles


Follow Flash